James Marsh revisits an amazing chimp named Nim in his tense new doc

Project Nim

on July 01, 2011 by Steve Ramos
Print

projectnimreview.pngThe incredibly true journey of a chimpanzee named Nim begins in 1973 at the Institute for Primate Studies in Norman, Oklahoma and continues to Columbia University laboratories to end somewhat sadly at an animal sanctuary in Texas. British filmmaker James Marsh recreates this tale of an ambitious primate language study through traditional face-the-camera interviews, clever graphics and dramatic recreations. A powerful musical score adds gravitas. Objectively, this is the story of a linguistic experiment, but intimately, this is the story of Nim Chimpsky (a pun on Noam Chomsky, the linguist who believed grammar was exclusive to humans). Nim was treated as a human in order to learn sign language, an experiment with many consequences. Expect Roadside Attractions, who bought U.S. theatrical rights at Sundance, to match the domestic earnings of Marsh's last doc, the Oscar winning Man On Wire.

Marsh and editor Jinx Godfrey establish the main characters quickly: Columbia University behavioral psychologist Professor Herbert Terrace leads the project with Nim's first caregiver, Stephanie LaFarge, his ex-student and ex-lover. Through their training and affection, their proxy child Nim grows more skilled with his sign languagebut simultaneously he grows larger and stronger. Suspense builds as Nim develops and becomes less content with his changing living conditions.

Marsh is comprehensive in gathering interviews from many of the people who worked with Nim. He also completes what Terrace and his colleagues at Columbia intended to do through sign language: make Nim a dynamic human-like character that tugs at your heartstrings, wins you over with language and then frightens you with violence. The film's climactic scene, when LaFarge reunites with Nim after many years inside his cage at a Texas animal sanctuary, is as frightening as can be found in any horror movie.

Behind the well-placed jolts, cameraman Michael Simmonds' tense dramatic recreations and Dickon Hinchliffe's atmospheric music, Marsh continues to emphasize the core questions about the project: How successful was Terrace at redrawing the line between humans and animals? Was it right for LaFarge to treat Nim like a baby instead of a pet?

Marsh blurs the boundaries between non-fiction and fictional film with Project Nim, which premiered in the World Cinema Documentary Competition at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival. It's a filmmaking style Marsh began with his early documentary Wisconsin Death Trip and continued to perfect through Man On Wire, the story of French high-wire artist Philippe Petit and his 1974 walk between the Twin Towers of New York's World Trade Center.

Though impressive, Project Nim dazzles a little less than Man On Wire. Marsh's best film to date is actually not a documentary but a thriller: Red Riding: 1980, his feature-length installment of the Red Riding Trilogy, an incredible three-film drama about the Yorkshire Ripper.

Still, with an Academy Award under his belt, Marsh continues to build a following among U.S. specialty film fans. Positive reviews and coverage regarding the validity of such animal experiments will help reintroduce Nim Chimpsky's story to audiences who remember the original stories as well as those learning about Nim for the first time.

Distributor: Roadside Attractions/HBO Documentary Films
Director: James Marsh
Producers: Simon Chinn
Genre: Documentary
Rating: PG-13 for some strong language, drug content, thematic elements and disturbing images.
Running time: 93 min.
Release: July 8 NY/CHI, July 15 EXP.

 

Tags: James Marsh, Simon Chinn
Print

read all Reviews »


1 Comment

What do you think?